Repair or Replace: Deciding What to Do When Your Roof is Damaged

by | Jun 16, 2023 | Blog, Newnan, Roof Damage, Roof Repair, Roof Replacement



When faced with roof damage, homeowners often find themselves in a dilemma: should they repair the affected areas or opt for a complete roof replacement? In such situations, seeking guidance from a trusted roofing professional becomes crucial. Hero Roofing, based in Newnan, is one such reliable company that can assess the situation and help you make an informed decision.

While consulting a roofing expert is essential, it’s also beneficial to conduct some preliminary research. To assist you in your decision-making process, here are a few key considerations when determining whether to repair or replace your roof.

Age of the Roof 

Different types of roofing systems have varying lifespans. For instance, asphalt roofs typically last around 20 years, while metal roofs can endure for nearly 50 years. If you notice signs of deterioration on an older roof, replacing the entire system might be a wise choice. Continually repairing specific areas could end up being a waste of money in the long run.

roof replacement, roof repair, roof damage, NewnanHero Roofing Roofing Contractor (3)

Leaky Roof 

A leaking roof is one of the most common reasons for repair or replacement. Locating the source of a leak can be challenging, as water often flows to different areas. Fortunately, the knowledgeable team at Hero Roofing excels in detecting areas of damage and can quickly address roof repairs if necessary.

Ignoring a leaky roof can lead to additional complications. Mold growth, damaged ceilings, compromised insulation, or even rotting frames may require attention, making it even more crucial to address the issue promptly.

Extent of Damage 

When assessing your roof, pay attention to the following signs of damage:

  • Worn and aged roofing material
  • Growth of moss, algae, or mildew on the surface
  • Curled, broken, or cracked shingles
  • Missing granules or bald spots on the shingles
  • Dents in metal roofing
  • Rust on fasteners, shingles, or panels

Depending on the severity of the damage in these areas, you can determine whether repairs or a complete roof replacement are necessary.

Improper Ventilation 

Proper ventilation is vital for maintaining the health of your roof. If you observe condensation forming on the underside of your roof deck or struggle to keep your attic or second-story comfortable during hot summer days, it may indicate insufficient ventilation in your attic area. Inadequate ventilation can lead to various issues and impact the condition of your roof.

In addition to affecting your current roofing system, improper ventilation can also contribute to future repair needs. It’s important to recognize the significance of adequate airflow to ensure the longevity of your roof. By addressing ventilation problems, you can help prevent potential damages and extend the lifespan of your roof.


While cost is an important aspect to consider when deciding between repairing or replacing your damaged roof, it should not be the sole determining factor. While roof repairs are generally more affordable in the short term, extensive damage may make a complete roof replacement a more cost-effective option in the long run. It is essential to rely on the expertise of professionals like Hero Roofing who can conduct a thorough inspection and evaluation of the damage, taking into account factors such as the extent of the damage, the age of the roof, and the overall condition of the roofing system. By considering all these factors, you can make an informed decision that balances both immediate costs and long-term value.

To the untrained eye, a roof may appear to be in good condition. Most homeowners do not interact with their roofs on a daily basis, which is why consulting a reputable roofing contractor in Newnan like Hero Roofing is crucial. With our expertise and experience, we can assess the condition of your roof and determine how much longer the current system will last. In some cases, a repair might be the best immediate option, with a plan for a new roof in the future.

At Hero Roofing, your best interests are always a priority. We offer free inspections to help you decide whether a roof repair or replacement is the most suitable choice for your specific situation.